Statistical inference in randomized consent designs in the presence of Hawthorne
نویسنده
چکیده
Randomized consent designs have been advocated in some setting. It has been argued that the use of the randomized consent designs is justified as it eliminates the so-called Hawthorne effect in the control group. Besides the ethical issue in not informing the patients, there are other potentially serious issues regarding the confounding and resultant bias in treatment comparison. This is particularly so in behavioral intervention trials. There is not only the placebo effect, but also the so-called Hawthorn effect that could muddy the comparisons. Based on a randomized consent design with control and intervention which results in three distinct groups, this presentation will show using very simple statistical contrasts why unbiased comparison is impossible due to confounding and self-selection.
منابع مشابه
Review of the Applications of Exponential Family in Statistical Inference
In this paper, after introducing exponential family and a history of work done by researchers in the field of statistics, some applications of this family in statistical inference especially in estimation problem,statistical hypothesis testing and statistical information theory concepts will be discussed.
متن کاملFitting a routine health-care activity into a randomized trial: an experiment possible without informed consent?
Due to possible methodological and practical problems, many researchers refrain from using a randomized controlled trial design to evaluate procedures already embedded in routine health care. We performed a randomized controlled trial on the effects of routine individual feedback on test ordering behavior of family physicians. The trial started after 4 years of feedback and lasted for 2.5 years...
متن کاملA COMPREHENSIVE STUDY ON THE CONCRETE COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH ESTIMATION USING ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK AND ADAPTIVE NEURO-FUZZY INFERENCE SYSTEM
This research deals with the development and comparison of two data-driven models, i.e., Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Adaptive Neuro-based Fuzzy Inference System (ANFIS) models for estimation of 28-day compressive strength of concrete for 160 different mix designs. These various mix designs are constructed based on seven different parameters, i.e., 3/4 mm sand, 3/8 mm sand, cement conten...
متن کاملProcrustean statistical inference of deformations
A two step method has been devised for the statistical inference of deformation changes. In the first step of this method and based on Procrustes analysis of deformation tensors, the significance of the change in a time or space series of deformation tensors is statistically analyzed. In the second step significant change(s) in deformations are localized. In other words, they are assigned to ce...
متن کاملClustered encouragement designs with individual noncompliance: bayesian inference with randomization, and application to advance directive forms.
In many studies comparing a new 'target treatment' with a control target treatment, the received treatment does not always agree with assigned treatment-that is, the compliance is imperfect. An obvious example arises when ethical or practical constraints prevent even the randomized assignment of receipt of the new target treatment but allow the randomized assignment of the encouragement to rece...
متن کامل